Forgot to mention yesterday... I bought Land O Lakes butter yesterday from Harris Teeter. I had a $0.55 coupon but I think there are $0.40 and $0.35 coupons floating around in newspapers. It's also on sale for $1.50 right now.
If you purchase one package of Land O Lakes butter with olive oil you can get a coupon for a free package next time! So basically I bought the butter that Stephen prefers (because it has olive oil in it) for $0.40 and I'll get a coupon for a free package worth $2.39. Yum!!
Go here for the rebate form.